I am starting an international investment fund, should I set it up as an LLC or an S-Corp?
Quick Comparison: LLC vs. S-CorporationDifference in income allocation:While S-Corporation special tax status eliminates double taxation, it lacks the flexibility of an LLC in allocating income to the owners. An LLC may offer several classes of membership interests, while an S-Corporation may only have one class of stock.Ownership restrictions:Any number of individuals or entities may own interest in an LLC. Also, LLCs are allowed to have subsidiaries without restriction. Ownership interest in an S-Corporation is limited to no more than 100 shareholders. On top of that S-Corporations cannot be owned by C-Corporations, other S-Corporations, many trusts, LLCs, partnerships, or non-resident aliens.Self-Employment Taxes:One advantage of S-Corporation is the way self employment taxes are calculated. S-Corporation owners employed by the company must receive salary, and their self employemnt tax is caluclated based on that salary (this is true with the exception of S-Corporations based in New York City). Owners of LLC, on the other hand, pay self employment taxes based on all member distributions they receive.S-Corporation:S-Corporation is a regular corporation that has 100 shareholders or less and that passes-through net income or losses to its shareholders for tax purposes (similar to sole proprietorship or partnership). Since all corporate income is "passed through" directly to the shareholders who include the income on their individual tax returns, S Corporation are not subject to double taxation.An eligible domestic corporation (C-Corporation) can avoid double taxation (once to the corporation and again to the shareholders) by electing to be treated as an S Corporation. Generally, an S Corporation is exempt from federal income tax other than tax on certain capital gains and passive income. On their tax returns, the S Corporation's shareholders include their share of the corporation's income or loss.S-Corporation vs. C-CorporationAdvantages:Like C-Corporations, S-Corporations are separate legal entities from their shareholders and, under state laws, generally provide their shareholders with the same liability protection afforded to the shareholders of C corporations.Unlike C-Corporations, for Federal income tax purposes taxation of S corporations resembles that of partnerships. Thus, income is taxed at the shareholder level and not at the corporate level.Certain corporate penalty taxes (e.g., accumulated earnings tax, personal holding company tax) and the alternative minimum tax do not apply to an S-Corporation.Disadvantages:Unlike a C-Corporation, an S-Corporation is not eligible for a dividends received deduction (a tax deduction received by a corporation on the dividends paid to it by other corporations in which it has an ownership stake).Unlike a C-Corporation, an S-Corporation is not subject to the 10% of taxable income limitation applicable to charitable contribution deductions.Unlike a C-Corporation, ownership of an S-Corporation is significantly restricted (read next).Who Can Form an S-Corporation?S-Corporations are more suitable for small and family businesses, and for those who start their business with small investment. Also, some existing businesses qualify for S-Corporation status.To form S-Corporation or to change your existing C-Corporation into S-Corporation (also called " Election of S-Corporation Status") certain conditions must be met:S-Corporation cannot have more than 100 shareholders.All shareholders must be either U.S. citizens or residents, estates, or certain trusts.Can only have one class of stock. Preferred stock is not allowed.Profits and losses must be accorded to owners in proportion with their ownership stake.Must use the calendar year as its fiscal year unless it can demonstrate to the IRS that another fiscal year satisfies a business purpose.Shareholders cannot deduct losses in excess of their investment.The corporation cannot deduct fringe benefits given to employees who own more than 2% of the corporation.Filing With IRS And The StateS-Corporation Election is filed with the IRS (Election by a Small Business Corporation, Form 2553), and that election is recognized by all states. with the exception of New York, New Jersey and Arkansas, which require additional state filing.S-Corporation AdvantagesForming S-Corporation generally allows you to pass business losses through to your personal income tax return, where you can use it to offset any income that you have from other sources.S-Corporation shareholders are not subject to self-employment taxes. These taxes, which add up to more than 15% of your income, are used to pay your Social Security and Medicare taxes.When you sell your S-Corporation, your taxable gain on the sale of the business can be less than it would have been had you operated the business as a regular corporation.Taxation of S-CorporationsAs already mentioned above, S-Corporations are not subject to corporate tax rates. Instead, S-Corporation passes-through profit (or net losses) to its shareholders and those profits are taxed at individual tax rates on each shareholder's Form 1040. The pass-through (sometimes called "flow-through") nature of the income means that the S-Corporation's profits are only taxed once - at the shareholder level. The IRS explains it this way: "On their tax returns, the S-Corporation's shareholders include their share of the corporation's separately stated items of income, deduction, loss, and credit, and their share of non-separately stated income or loss".S-Corporations therefore avoid the so-called "double taxation" of dividends in most states. There are however two exceptions to this rule:California: There is a franchise tax of 1.5% of net income of an S-Corporation (minimum $800). This is one factor to be taken into consideration when choosing between an LLC and an S-corporation in California. On highly profitable enterprises, the LLC franchise tax fees, which are based on gross revenues, may be lower than the 1.5% net income tax. Conversely, on high gross revenue, low profit-margin businesses, the LLC franchise tax fees may exceed the S-Corporation net income tax.New York City: S-Corporations are subject to the full corporate income tax at a 8.85% rate. However if the S-Corporation can demonstrate that a portion of its business was done outside the city, that portion will not be subject to the additional tax.Retaining Profits of S-CorporationS-Corporations (much like regular C-Corporations) are allowed to retain their net profits as operating capital. However, all profits are considered as if they were distributed to shareholders, and as a result shareholders might be taxed on income they never received (whereas a shareholder of C-corporation is taxed on dividends only when those dividends are actually paid out).Converting S-Corporation Back to C-CorporationS-Corporation status is not permanent and can be reversed back if so desired. For example, if the business becomes more profitable and there are tax advantages to being a regular C-Corporation, S-Corporation registration status can be dropped after a certain amount of time.